Title Script Right by Writer Name Harri Sargeant Script title Knock Genre Sci fi Format Short film No of pages 20 Primary reader Immediate thoughts Slightly concerned that in dialogue headers Fred s called Frederick but in the script at times he is referred to as Fred Pick one and stick with it So is he in deep space or not I m so confused when Fred mentions the local atmosphere Is he in the atmosphere of a planet then Inside a Dyson sphere or something The opening made it sound like he was in a nebula or something Not sure nebulae have atmospheres P14 I m intrigued to know how Fred worked out the black abyss was the result of a supernova and furthermore the idea that it s a galaxy eater It seems obvious now that 1
Title  Script Right  by Writer  Name  Harri Sargeant Script title  Knock Genre  Sci-fi Format  Short film No. of pages  20...
Title Script Right by Writer they re in a black hole or somesuch but black holes don t look like clouds and furthermore galaxies tend to be a lot bigger than black holes In fact there s a theory that there s a big black hole at the centre of every galaxy around which everything else in the galaxy orbits I m trying not to be too pedantic about the science especially when every other aspect of the script is so on point honest o Then again this could not be a black hole It could be something else But then why mention the supernova at all when so far all we know supernovae produce are black holes Okay the distance Laika travelled is given as the indication for Fred knowing the abyss is expanding That seems reasonable Action P1 The description at the start is beautifully written but maybe a tiny bit too prose Nice ominous opening visual though Use of planetary words like horizon and atmosphere don t really fit in deep space either If the scene heading said we were inside a nebula or something I wouldn t quibble o Laika as the name for the probe is a nice touch for all you space canine fans Like the weightlessness aspect of the script always good to see that in science fiction scripts P2 I d assumed the video was a recording but it seems to be a live feed This is probably me being pedantic but I doubt we ll have solved the time delay aspect of communications in the next 10 years of space travel A recording might be more appropriate not just from a scientific perspective but also helping to isolate the character Then again people might say it s too close to Interstellar P3 I m sure by horizon the writer means background Again just me being a picky so and so but the word choice is bugging me a bit Would a fade or some kind of transition be okay on p 7 Or would a jump cut to a dream sequence be creepier more unsettling Do we need the new scene heading It s all the same scene right P8 The knocking with the screeching and whispering is properly unnerving I can hear it in my head now P13 The floating tears are a nice touch The descriptions are all evocative and atmospheric if skirting a little too close to prose on occasion The visuals are very cinematic this is one I could picture in my head as I read on no problem 2
Title  Script Right  by Writer  they   re in a black hole or somesuch, but black holes don   t look like clouds, and furth...
Script Right Title by Writer Structure P20 Wow that ending The ending is nice grim as hell but really doubles down on the darkness and isolation I had chills They multiplied However wouldn t the whole ship s internal atmosphere start venting out into space when the hull is breached I get that at first it s in a room that s sealed off but when the creatures smash the door into the camera feed the rest of the ship s air should be getting pulled out into the vacuum right I m not sure if we need the abyss expanding to endanger all life on earth aspect of the plot Just Frederick trying to cope with being along in a void with something for company and a loosening grip on his sanity is enough for a short film Were this a feature then the expansion subplot would probably be necessary The pace is slow but determined with a gradual building up of the tension and dread Very similar to Alien in that regard which also harked back to slow build of 2001 The montage is nice Could fred get more haggard at it progresses as a supplement to the notches on the wall as the loneliness and constant fear of death take their toll Dialogue P4 The message in voiceover gave me goose pimples I like the matter of fact almost polite tone The nature of the black somethings is nice Fear of the unknown and all that Think the phrase weird death demons is a bit odd though Not what I d have said myself P5 Juxtaposition of the ballet and the I think I m losing it already is a lovely touch P6 This last bit of the message before the THE ABYSS scene heading feels a bit too on the nose I d suggest cutting the bit between I hope you get them And Everyone at home I love you Leave the hoping humanity isn t doomed bit implicit Similarly with the I wish I could be there to celebrate We can assume that it doesn t necessarily have to be said Just the happy birthday bit said in the right sort of tone would convey that I think I m not sure about the line I m probably just a footnote in their happiness by now Feels a bit disingenuous and purple It s a shame as most of the dialogue has been good The dialogue is largely well written and mostly avoid being on the nose Genre tone The classical music bit is that diagetic or not Not a criticism just asking 3
Script Right  Title  by Writer  Structure -  P20. Wow, that ending. The ending is nice, grim as hell, but really doubles d...
Title Script Right o by Writer Also hasn t the classical music in space been done to death since 2001 A Space Odyssey With the spherical spaceship too I m getting very strong 2001 vibes For once I d like to see a film where someone in space listens to early blues or freestyle jazz or even Brian Eno or something Oh so the music was non diagetic then Personally I d have thought the message would play better without musical accompaniment Depends on the classical music piece in question I guess but the sort of balletic type of music you d need for the syncing of the pong game etc probably wouldn t go with the ominous message thing Unless you re going for complete tonal juxtaposition just to convey the alienness of the situation in which case fair enough P7 Hang on so it is diagetic then I am so confused This needs clearing up Secondary reader Immediate thoughts The first paragraph creates a serene mood readying us for a story of dark beauty Nice juxtaposition of normality and deep space Morning is a nice way of dealing with the ambiguous time of day How is he so sure the darkness is going to kill everyone on earth too He explains later they ve got new readings explaining what the darkness is but at this point how does he know Me and your mum always shared our toys typo Peeing into a hoover wearing the tiara again offers bitter sweetness Structure The first page and half simply offers us a grasp of the normality of this world we then learn his desire to have the people of his earth his family receive his messages however he has little hope for this he s pretty much accepted he s going to die he has six months to survive from the off it feels like perhaps this should take a little longer or his descent towards death should have a more extreme level of growth 267 days in and he s still got hope but as the story continues we see it drain out of him The biggest issue with this structure is the tragic ending if he had a flaw which he kept on relying upon he would deserve a sad ending however in this case he s a man 4
Title  Script Right  o  by Writer  Also hasn   t the classical music in space been done to death since 2001  A Space Odyss...
Script Right Title by Writer trying to cling onto hope that he will see his family again making a routine for himself the darkness is coming and he knows deep down it s going to get him But it feels like a bit of a dud ending to then quite simply have the darkness get him There doesn t necessarily need to be a massive twist Perhaps he should escape or wake up somewhere heavenly and we are at least left to speculate about the sadness of the ending did he get away or is he just dead and in some sort of paradise 2001 Space Odyssey a film which can easily compared to this script thanks to the gentle slow pace in space with classical music is obviously a film on a much larger scale than this however we do see a man reach the end of his life we then see a foetus the meaning can be debated but it seems even when this man s life has ended he is born again An ending like this with ambiguous hope seems like it would be much more suitable for a short film which has set up such a firm ending for itself You ve told us what s going to happen it happens it doesn t feel fulfilling Characterisation Seeing Frederick in a pink tiara on the second page undermines any overblown masculinity separating him from the droning sci fi men of recent years e g George Clooney Matthew Maconaheyhey this is refreshing Frederick is easy to empathise with he s lonely for external reasons which makes us want to see him find company yet he still has hope and makes a new life for himself in this strange environment which is admirable The only thing I d suggest is making his loneliness more of a damaging flaw we see a burst of rage when his family can t see him perhaps this should be brought in earlier or we should see him shake Laika or even have Laika trying to offer a report but he ignores Laika then he can find the hope again and have a dance he just seems to have quite a static journey at the moment the darkness enshrouds he gets more isolated and slightly less sane let s see those cracks of darkness come out in him Having the family fighting as something Frederick misses is a very nice moment of pathos Could we get a little more idiosyncrasy from the family Even if it s just Frederick referencing it it would be a nice poignant addition to hear about the weird thing his kids used to do Dialogue 5
Script Right  Title  by Writer  trying to cling onto hope that he will see his family again, making a routine for himself,...
Script Right Title by Writer The line I don t know what they are or what they want is followed by all I know is they want to kill me this seems contradictory Weird death demons sounds a little bit off maybe he should have given them a weird name by now Gross feels a little bit immature or it might just be the exclamation mark he s come across this dirt before I don t think he should react with such disgust Generally some of the dialogue could be cut you ve got a very visual story you should use it and let us just watch Frederick floating in isolation doing little things to keep himself occupied Then you can turn those little things into slightly weirder things as time goes on and he starts to lose his mind Some of the dialogue sticks out as being overly poetic for a man who tends to speak quite plainly e g The last man in the universe is a simple true statement he seems to be saying in order to come to terms with it whereas I m probably just a footnote in their happiness by now feels like indulgence Morning honey to Laika is a really nice line that has a nice pay off Genre tone From the first line we get this is sci fi dark beautiful and slow There s not a huge amount of subversion but that s not a terrible thing when the script is executed so well much like the plot you set out what it is and you give it to us in a high quality controlled manner Comparing it to other texts it feels somewhere between 2001 Space Odyssey and The Doctor Who episode Midnight It s a damn nice place for a script to sit Additional feedback Immediate thoughts Knock is an intense contained short that focuses on a character s attempt to stay sane The pacing is brilliant and the character s attempt to maintain his sanity is engaging Overall this was a fun read with great imagery and tone that sucks the reader in The issue of the knocking could be addressed better is it a personification of his insanity Aliens Maybe have knocking occur in other places towards the end to help show his 6
Script Right  -  Title  by Writer  The line    I don   t know what they are, or what they want    is followed by    all I ...
Script Right Title by Writer impending insanity Otherwise it s a great short that could even make an interesting first part to a Doctor Who episode Who knows Action Minor qualms with format and characterisation should be addressed but these are issues that can be dealt with a simple redraft There are errors in formatting as well The montage isn t labelled as ending so at the point where he s either spinning or smiling on page 11 write MONTAGE ENDS The intercut where Fred s VO is heard over readings of Laika s Data but it should have the scene heading where he s talking straight to the camera on screen as it s a different point in time Terms like He sits at the desk processing data Shouldn t be used instead show the audience what he does to process the data like inputting it himself looking over details on different programs etc show don t tell Characterisation Frederick is an affable protagonist but he takes a lack of action As an astronaut it would be better if he tried to do something to better understand the data that Laika brings back If Frederick was testing the soot or attempted to process the data in a different way like making a chart or comparing the different readings etc it would provide him with action suitable of his role This can then be counterbalanced with his attempt to stay sane with each test coming back with worse results it can build up towards Frederick s major breaking point loss of hope optional Also if Frederick s on a ship and not a space station he can at least attempt to move the ship to get to a better place to send messages or gain better test results If the location was changed to a space station this couldn t be done but with a ship this seems like a possibility Additional feedback Immediate thoughts Moon meets Solaris in this awesome little sci fi A man alone in space with an object for a companion like all stories set in space with an antagonistic force isolating the protagonist comparisons with 2001 are almost clich d but true 7
Script Right  Title  by Writer  impending insanity   Otherwise, it   s a great short that could even make an interesting f...
Title Script Right by Writer Frederick is quite the dancer and at the end I m pretty sure he s literally dancing with death Right after death was literally knocking on his door It could be read as a story of a man who ignores death almost in denial of it but ultimately succumbs to it finally accepting it Structure The story itself whilst not really breaking any new ground and perhaps a less optimistic version of the Martian is executed so well that the conceit of it all hardly matters I mention the Martian because the protagonists are quite similar in a similar situation both a little unconventional in their personalities and slightly wise crackey given their circumstances though Frederick slightly more unhinged Laika s demise serves the purpose of cementing Frederick visions as something purely from his mind as opposed to what we find out in Solaris it s as if he sees his own personal Heaven before him Characterisation Using Laika the robot companion and getting us to warm to this inanimate object is a tricky thing to do but by Boy George do you do it All the more heart breaking then when Laika is stripped from our protagonist s hands prematurely much like his family It s a nice little technique Genre tone It s a no brainer to enjoy a sci fi piece that s executed well because I do love me some spacey sci fi especially sci fi horrors THE SCRIPT RIGHT VERDICT Beauty is conveyed beautifully A simple effective story A terrific use of sound and vision The dialogue could be cut down and improved 8
Title  Script Right  -  by Writer  Frederick is quite the dancer and at the end I   m pretty sure he   s literally dancing...
Script Right Title The structure could be reworked a little Some formatting issues 9 by Writer
Script Right  Title  - The structure could be reworked a little. - Some formatting issues.  9  by Writer